📷 2
Photos
Shot by a City Insiders curator.
Devil's Advocate
★ 4.0(1 review)Bar
atmosphericsophisticatedhistoric
About the Vibe
Tucked away up Advocate's Close in a Victorian pump house, Devil's Advocate is Edinburgh's whisky bar that actually lives up to the hype. With over 300 bottles on the shelf and a kitchen turning out solid modern Scottish plates, it's the rare spot that works equally well for a pre-theatre dram or a full dinner. Yes, everyone knows about it — but the brick-walled atmosphere and genuinely knowledgeable bartenders keep it from feeling like a tourist trap.
Why it's worth it
Over 300 whiskys, a Victorian pump house setting, and a kitchen that punches above its weight — Edinburgh's most beloved whisky bar lives up to the hype.
Highlights
300+ whiskyscocktails maisonterrasseVictorian setting
Before you go
Book ahead for dinner — it gets busy with both tourists and locals, especially on weekends and during the Festival.
Known For
- •300+ whisky selection
- •cocktails maison
- •modern Scottish food
- •Victorian pump house setting
Best For
whisky tastingpre-theatre drinksdinner with drinks
1 review
City InsidersEditorialMarch 31, 2026
Whisky heaven in a Victorian setting
Devil's Advocate is one of those Edinburgh institutions that manages to feel both special and genuinely welcoming — no small feat when you're this well-known. The setting is the first thing that hits you: a Victorian pump house tucked up Advocate's Close, all exposed brick and warm lighting, with a mezzanine dining area that makes the space feel intimate despite the crowds. The whisky selection is the real star here — over 300 bottles ranging from everyday single malts to rare blends you won't find elsewhere — and the bartenders actually know what they're talking about. Ask for a recommendation and you'll get something thoughtful, not just the most expensive pour.
The food menu is solidly modern Scottish, with seasonal ingredients and dishes that complement the drinks rather than compete with them. Reviewers consistently praise the burgers and the cocktails, and the kitchen holds its own even if it's not the main event. The terrace is a genuine bonus in good weather, and they're dog-friendly out there too. Just be aware: the historic building means stairs, and it's not fully accessible — worth noting if mobility is a concern.
It's not a hidden gem anymore, and you'll hear plenty of accents from around the world, but it remains one of Edinburgh's better whisky bars. The vibe is sophisticated without being stuffy, and it works for everything from a quick pre-theatre drink to a proper dinner. Go for the whisky, stay for the atmosphere.