📷 2
Photos
Shot by a City Insiders curator.
Pistachio & Pickle
★ 4.0(1 review)Café
cozylocalcharming
About the Vibe
Tucked away on the cobbled charm of Camden Passage, Pistachio & Pickle is Islington's answer to the perfect cheese obsession. Forget the tourist traps—this is where locals queue for toasties that actually deliver on the gooey, crispy promise. The upstairs dining nook is stripped-back but cozy, perfect for sinking into a wooden board with a melt-in-your-mouth cheese toastie and a glass of wine.
Known For
- •best cheese toasties in London
- •award-winning artisanal British cheeses
- •upstairs dining with wine
- •celebration cheese cakes
Best For
solo lunchcheese tastingcasual date
1 review
City InsidersEditorialApril 8, 2026
The Best Cheese Toastie in Islington
Pistachio & Pickle Dairy is a true Islington treasure that feels like a well-kept secret. The classic grilled cheese toastie is the star here—perfectly golden, with a satisfying cheese pull that's neither too fancy nor over-complicated. The bread-to-cheese ratio is spot on, and the addition of finely sliced spring onions adds a nice fresh touch. If you can, grab a seat upstairs where the stripped-back space and cobbled passage views create a lovely atmosphere for a relaxed meal.
The cheese selection downstairs is impressive, with a wide range of artisanal British cheeses, chutneys, and pickled treats that make for great takeaway bags or impromptu cheese boards. While it's not the most spacious spot, the charm more than makes up for it. This is the kind of place you'll find yourself returning to again and again for that perfect comfort food fix.